The history of the West is not quite what you learned in school
Josephine Quinn’s new book re-examines what people think they know about civilisations
Asked what he thought of Western civilisation, Mahatma Gandhi is said to have quipped that such a thing “would be a good idea”. (The West, he suggested, was not so enlightened.) But as Josephine Quinn makes clear in her new book, Western civilisation has always been a bad idea, or at any rate a wrong-headed one. To compartmentalise history into a set of distinct and essentially self-contained civilisations is a misguided quest that has dangerously distorted our understanding of the world, Ms Quinn asserts: “It is not peoples that make history, but people, and the connections that they create with one another.”
Ms Quinn, a historian and archaeologist who teaches at Oxford, does not spend 500-odd pages trashing what generations of schoolchildren have been taught to take pride in as European achievements. Instead, she demolishes the underlying concept of what she calls “civilisational thinking”. Her argument is simple, persuasive and deserving of attention.
This article appeared in the Culture section of the print edition under the headline "And you call yourself civilised?"
Culture March 9th 2024
More from Culture
Is this the greatest ever Premier League season?
The race between Manchester City, Arsenal and Liverpool masks issues at the bottom of the table
Romantasy brings dragons and eroticism together. At last
Novels starring hot fairies are selling millions of copies
Who’s afraid of Judith Butler, the “godmother of queer theory”?
A new book highlights Judith Butler’s fierceness and blind spots