The end of the debate
The president turns a globally respected American institution into a national embarrassment
AMONG THE institutions Donald Trump has attacked in the past three and a half years, the televised presidential debate might not seem much. It does not guarantee the rule of law, protect the environment or defend the homeland. It has hardly ever been electorally significant. Maybe only the first televised duel, which pitted a sweaty, shady looking Richard Nixon against a youthful, make-up wearing John Kennedy in 1960, materially affected a race. Yet at a time when some of the most basic assumptions about American democracy are being challenged by Mr Trump’s scorched-earth presidency, as he illustrated with a debate performance of stunning brutishness in Cleveland on September 29th, the merits of the format are worth recalling.
Before this week they were threefold. The president, setting aside the exalted status and electoral advantages of incumbency, must submit to the same pre-agreed rules as his challenger. (No president since Nixon, following his humiliation in 1960, has ducked the format.) Second—and notwithstanding a mountain of evidence that most people do not vote on the basis of such things—debates affirm the importance of plans and ideas. This projects a degree of seriousness that is otherwise largely absent from most political coverage.
This article appeared in the United States section of the print edition under the headline "The end of the debate"
United States October 3rd 2020
- Why Donald Trump is doing surprisingly well in Florida
- Would the Supreme Court hand Donald Trump a second term?
- Why do voters in Georgia face so many hurdles to voting?
- Measuring poverty in the midst of America’s covid-19 epidemic
- Priestly guidance on voting is dividing the Catholic church in America
- The end of the debate
More from United States
Bayer wants legislative help to fight its cancer lawsuits
But the maker of Roundup weedkiller faces opposition from Republican and Democratic hardliners
After a season of Gaza protests, America’s university graduates are polarised but resilient
After enduring covid and turmoil over free speech, the class of 2024 finally takes its bow
Can playing cards help catch criminals?
A novel idea for solving cold cases comes with high-stakes risks